Maraschino Cherry Ice Cream Sandwiches

Maraschino Cherry Ice Cream Sandwiches

I love challenges — especially food challenges — and I love to great creative with food.

Recently, I was given the opportunity to create a dessert recipe inspired by one of the new Renuzit Tempting Indulgences air freshener cones. Not your typical challenge, right? But that’s why I like it! I was sent two of the new Renuzit cones to smell and get inspired by: Crème Brûlée and Chocolate Covered Cherries.

I got busy planning. I decided ice cream sandwiches were a must for this challenge because I had recently bought an ice cream sandwich maker on clearance at Walmart and I was dying to use it. I decided I would do a cherry ice cream and “cover” it with chocolate cookies to make my sandwiches.

NOTE: You don’t need the Ice Cream Sandwich Maker to make this recipe — you can use any chocolate cookie recipe of your choice.

The Chocolate Covered Cherries scent was a perfect match for my sandwiches! I headed to Walmart to pick up ingredients to make a homemade Maraschino Cherry Ice Cream. One of the main ingredients (obviously) are maraschino cherries….

…and whipping cream. I took a lot more photos during my shopping trip — you can see a slideshow of them here.

The first step is to get your ice cream base ready. It’s a mixture of whole milk, sugar, whipping cream, vanilla extract, and the maraschino cherry juice (from the jar). Mix all this up and put it in the refrigerator to chill.

While the ice cream base hangs out in the refrigerator, you’ll cut up your cherries into fourths.

Following the directions of your ice cream maker, place the ice cream base into your maker. Don’t add the cherries yet! You will add your cherries when the mixture is thickened — about 5-10 minutes before it’s done.

While your ice cream is freezing, work on your cookies for your ice cream sandwiches. I have this electric ice cream sandwich maker that helps me make the cookies, but if you don’t have one, you can make any chocolate cookie recipe in your oven.

My ice cream sandwich maker came with a handy tool that helps me to assemble the sandwiches. First I put down one of the cookies and then ice cream. I pushed the ice cream down so it would be more even and then I topped it with another cookie.

NOTE: You don’t have to have this to make the sandwiches — I have included instructions at the end for making your ice cream sandwiches without a press.

Each sandwich was immediately wrapped in plastic wrap and placed in the freezer.

Keep in your freezer until ready to enjoy.

If you want to dress these up a bit, you can roll the edges in sprinkles (which my kids enjoyed).

Of course, if you don’t want to make ice cream sandwiches, the Maraschino Cherry Ice Cream is great on its own too.

Maraschino Cherry Ice Cream Sandwiches
Nutrition Information
  • Serves: Makes approximately 1½ quarts of ice cream and approximately enough ice cream for 12 ice cream sandwiches with a 3\" diameter
  • Serving size: 12
  • 1 cup whole milk
  • ½ cup granulated sugar
  • 2¼ cups heavy whipping cream
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 10 oz. jar maraschino cherries, divided
  • 24 chocolate cookies (approx 3" diameter)
  1. In a chilled bowl, whisk together the milk and sugar until the sugar is dissolved. Stir in whipping cream, vanilla, and the cherry juice from the jar of maraschino cherries (not the cherries). Cover bowl and place in refrigerator.
  2. Cut maraschino cherries into quarters. Cover and refrigerate.
  3. Freeze ice cream base according to your ice cream maker instructions. When mixture is thickened, or approximately 5-10 minutes before it is done, add the cherries to the ice cream mixture in the ice cream maker.
  4. When ice cream is frozen, assemble ice cream sandwiches.
If you DO own the Homemade Ice Cream Sandwich Maker from Walmart:
  1. Follow the instructions that came with your product for using the ice cream sandwich press.
If you DO NOT own the Homemade Ice Cream Sandwich Maker:
  1. Find a cylinder item in your kitchen (with straight sides) that is close to the size of your cookies (such as clean can with with one end removed, a ramekin, a drinking glass, or a wide-mouth canning jar). Line the inside with a large piece of plastic wrap. Place 1 cookie inside in the bottom (flat edge upwards). Then add a layer of ice cream. Use another cylinder item that fits inside the first item to gently press down the ice cream so it's fairly even. Then top with a second cookie (flat side down towards the ice cream layer). Lift out the ice cream sandwich by lifting the plastic wrap. Wrap ice cream sandwich with the plastic wrap and freeze.
If you DO NOT have cylinder items in your home:
  1. Simply place one cookie down on work surface, flat side up. Top with ice cream and then top with another cookie, flat side down towards the ice cream. Wrap in plastic wrap and place in freezer.
Brownie Mix Chocolate Cookies (for use with Homemade Ice Cream Sandwich Maker from Walmart)
  • 18.4 - 19.8 oz box milk chocolate brownie mix
  • ½ cup vegetable oil
  • 2 large eggs
  1. Mix brownie mix, oil, and eggs in a bowl, until combined (don't over stir).
  2. Use 1 level tablespoon of batter for each cookie in the Ice Cream Sandwich Maker. Cook for approximately 1-2 minutes. Watch closely!
  3. To remove cookies from maker, use a fork and a spatula -- lift gently with the fork and slide spatula under edge, gradually working spatula further under the cookie with the help of the fork.

For more information on Renuzit and their new dessert scented air fresheners, visit:

Disclaimer: I am a member of the Collective Bias™ Social Fabric® Community.  This #TemptYourSenses shop has been compensated as part of a social shopper insights study for Collective Bias™ and Renuzit #CBias #SocialFabric

Like this post?
Subscribe to the free Home Cooking Memories Newsletter!


  1. says

    Look at you, you got a “maker” for everything :) It must be so much fun to play with all those toy! The ice cream sandwiches sound great!!

  2. says

    I love that cookie press, we love ice cream sandwiches so much, I might just have to buy one, your sandwiches look so yummy!!!

  3. says

    First, I am a maraschino cherry addict, I could devour a whole jar. Which is why I am loving your ice cream recipe! I had no idea there was a ice cream maker, now I need a new toy, YAY:-) They look delicious, what a perfect recipe for your challenge! 😉 Hugs, Terra

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: